- What does NPV actually mean?
- NPV is the dollar value a project adds at your required return. NPV = $0 means the project earns exactly your discount rate — no more, no less. NPV = $5,000 means the project adds $5,000 of value beyond what you'd earn putting the same money into an alternative at your discount rate. Negative NPV means the project earns less than the alternative — you'd be better off taking the discount-rate option. The decision rule is mechanical: accept if NPV > 0, reject if NPV < 0.
- How do I pick the discount rate?
- Three common choices. (1) Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) — what your firm pays for the blended mix of debt and equity it uses to fund projects. Most public companies disclose this. (2) The hurdle rate set by your finance team — typically WACC plus a project-risk premium (5-15 points more for risky projects, less for safe ones). (3) The opportunity cost — the return you could earn on the next-best project with similar risk. For personal use, use the return on a comparable investment you'd otherwise pick (e.g. 7-10% for an S&P 500 baseline). The NPV is highly sensitive to this number, so it's worth checking the result at a few rates.
- What's the difference between NPV and IRR?
- NPV gives you a dollar answer at a fixed discount rate; IRR gives you the percent return the project earns. For most go/no-go decisions they agree — if IRR exceeds your discount rate, NPV is positive, and vice versa. They can disagree when you're comparing two mutually exclusive projects of different sizes (NPV correctly favors the bigger absolute return; IRR can misleadingly favor the smaller, higher-percentage one). When NPV and IRR disagree on ranking, NPV is the right tiebreaker — you can't deposit a percentage in the bank.
- What if the cashflows have multiple sign changes?
- A project with cashflows like -1000, +600, -300, +800 has two sign changes (negative to positive, then back). Such 'non-conventional' projects can have multiple IRRs — multiple discount rates where NPV = 0 — making IRR meaningless as a single 'project return.' NPV remains well-defined and continues to be the right metric. The calculator's bisection finds the first IRR sign change in [-99%, +10000%]; if the project has multiple IRRs, only that one is reported. When in doubt with non-conventional cashflows, trust NPV.
- Can I enter negative cashflows for mid-life capex?
- Yes. Period 3 or 7 or 12 being negative is common — equipment refurbishment, regulatory remediation, a marketing push. Enter the period as a negative number; the calculator discounts it correctly. The Accept/Reject decision still uses the sign of NPV; the IRR may be undefined or non-unique if the cashflows oscillate (see the previous FAQ).
- Why does the initial investment appear in period 0 with a discount factor of 1?
- Money you spend today isn't discounted — it's already in today's dollars. The discount factor for period 0 is 1.000000 because (1+r)^0 = 1. Only future cashflows get discounted. This is why the formula is NPV = Σ [CF_t / (1+r)^t] for t=1..N minus the initial investment — the initial outlay is subtracted directly, not divided.
- Does NPV account for taxes and inflation?
- Only if you put them in. The cashflows you enter should be the actual after-tax cash you expect to receive — depreciation tax shields, operating cash, terminal value, etc., all netted. If you discount at a nominal rate (which includes inflation expectations), enter nominal cashflows; if you discount at a real rate, enter real cashflows. The most common mistake is mixing the two — discounting real cashflows at a nominal rate gives an artificially low NPV; the other way around overstates it.
- How does NPV handle projects with different lifespans?
- It doesn't, by default — NPV gives the total value added over each project's lifetime, but a 10-year project and a 5-year project aren't directly comparable on NPV alone (the 5-year project could be repeated to match horizons). For mutually exclusive projects with different lives, use the equivalent annual annuity (EAA) method: divide each project's NPV by the annuity factor for its life, getting a per-year equivalent. The project with the higher EAA wins. This calculator gives you the inputs; the comparison is yours to make.